
AMERICAN PRIMEVAL
Starring: Taylor Kitsch, Betty Gilpin, Dane DeHaan, Saura Lightfoot-Leon, Derek Hinkey, Kim Coates, Joe Tippett, Jai Courtney, Preston Mota, Shawnee Pourier, Lucas Neff, Alex Breaux, and Shea Whigham
Creator: Mark L. Smith

PRESTON

It’s impossible to know how close to truth it hits, but American Primeval is a delightfully shocking limited series about a very real historical event. Its gritty approach and brutal realism are complemented by chilling set designs and masterful cinematography, while the ending, although tragically unsatisfying, also is completely appropriate. Yes, you may have to forgive the creative liberties taken to paint the Mormons in such a negative light (however true they might have been for the time) and the muffled dialogue had my old-ass watching with subtitles, but this show is still a terrific “must watch” conversation-starter.

QUENTIN

While I didn’t exactly love Netflix’s American Primeval, my penchant to be more forgiving for gritty westerns nonetheless resulted in me enjoying it well enough despite a few nitpicks, the most egregious of which is Sara’s (Betty Gilpin) annoying, Karen-esque self-righteousness. That aside, the absolute brutality demonstrated on screen is surely accurate to the era, showcased through incredible cinematography and a production design so palpable that you can almost feel the blood on your face. It’s not always an easy watch, but at only six episodes, it’s probably one of the more authentic representations of the American West, which means it’s worth your time.