THE PIANO LESSON
Starring: Samuel L. Jackson, John David Washington, Ray Fisher, Michael Potts, Erykah Badu, Skylar Aleece Smith, Danielle Deadwyler, and Corey Hawkins
Director: Malcolm Washington
NICK
What you have here is another great addition to the August Wilson feature film list. As with many play adaptations, The Piano Lesson is a showcase of actors acting. John David Washington is the most charismatic he’s been since Ballers, Danielle Deadwyler should hear her name come Oscar time, and Ray Fisher gives what may be his strongest performance, period. It’s all put together by strong direction from Malcolm Washington (man, that’s a talented family), who does a good job getting that “film feel” within the confines of a single space. Let the August Wilson adaptations continue!
ADRIANO
The Piano Lesson sports an incredible ensemble of actors giving it their all, especially Danielle Deadwyler, who carries the movie every time she's on screen. Sadly, that ensemble is the film's brightest spot because, overall, I found the film to be pretty messy. It isn't awful, and unlike previous August Wilson adaptations (Fences and Ma Rainey's Black Bottom), director Malcolm Washington gives this more liveliness than a stagey feel. However, its themes of legacy and family are so lost in the film's many subplots that once the film reached its resolution, I didn't feel anything.
AMARÚ
The Piano Lesson is an actor’s showcase that puts director Malcolm Washington’s visual eye on full display in his feature debut. His intimate use of lighting and framing takes another August Wilson play that slightly suffers from being acts put to screen instead of a cinematic screenplay, and keeps your eyes fully focused on the talent relaying those lines. Its strong themes of legacy, history, and family are carried by a forceful ensemble and a chilling score, and even though I watched a play inside a television set, I also saw great actors do what they do. That alone was worth the watch.
KATIE
I was not surprised to learn that The Piano Lesson is an adaptation of a play since it’s very stagey without feeling cinematic. I was painfully aware that it takes place in a singular setting, which was exacerbated by the uneven pacing, misplaced score, and many lengthy monologues. I find that John David Washington usually lacks emotional range, but here he is almost too animated, especially compared to the other, more grounded yet impactful performances. Together with the many competing subplots, The Piano Lesson succeeds in showcasing some great actors, but it failed to grip me in any meaningful way.
This film was reviewed by Nick and Adriano as part of Bitesize Breakdown's coverage of the 2024 Toronto International Film Festival.