
MOANA
Starring: Catherine Laga'aia, Dwayne Johnson, John Tui, Frankie Adams, Rena Owen, and Jemaine Clement
Director: Thomas Kail

NICK
Much like last year’s How to Train Your Dragon, the live-action Moana was my introduction to the franchise. So, even though this was seemingly a shot-for-shot remake, it was new to me. That said, its flaws are apparent. Things don't start well as Catherine Laga'aia struggles to find her footing early on as Moana, but once "Disney Dwayne" appears on screen, his charisma instantly elevates her performance and lets her voice shine. Unfortunately, there's something missing in the transition to live-action as Moana relies too heavily on a distracting amount of CGI and ends up feeling quite shallow. It all adds up to another unnecessary remake.

ADRIANO
There’s nothing new about dunking on Disney live-action remakes. But for this one, its existence is extra confounding. Moana is exactly what studios want out of AI: take what's known, suck all the heart out of it, and hope audiences don’t care enough. Nothing has changed from the decade-old original, yet the live-action transition is dismal. It’s 95% CGI, and not good CGI, so everything about it feels drab and lifeless, and the weak performances from the two leads (Catherine Laga’aia and Dwayne Johnson) only add to the notable quality decline. This one broke me, I can’t lie.
