July 10, 2023
WRITTEN BY: ADRIANO
Emmy nominations are right around the corner, and things are much different this year because The Television Academy decided to shift its voting process from an unlimited ballot to a more simplified system that rewards passion. That change could make for a very different, and hopefully, much cleaner collection of nominees.
Since I have a lot to cover, let’s jump right in! Without further ado, I present my predictions for the 75th Primetime Emmy Award nominees. The official nominees will be announced on July 12, 2023.
DRAMA CATEGORIES
This year, the drama categories are bound to be dominated by one show in particular: Succession. All but guaranteed to win the top prize, you could honestly predict Succession in every drama category (where eligible) and it would be valid. Brian Cox’ confounding placement in the Lead Actor category aside, you can make a solid case that just about every actor from the series deserves to win. After being awarded the top prize for its previous two seasons, not to mention that this season - its final season - was the series’ most critically acclaimed, make no mistake… Succession is going out with a bang!
As for the non-Succession shows, place your bets on good years for Better Call Saul, The Last of Us, and The White Lotus, all of which are primed for nominations in Series and Acting. Next up, most likely, are Emmy darling The Crown and newcomer Andor, though maybe not as likely as the aforementioned shows due to the latter’s lack of popularity and the former’s mixed reception. That said, their performances at the winter awards point to a decent nomination haul.
Other shows that could perform well and earn a nomination for the top prize are returning Emmy juggernauts Yellowjackets and The Handmaid’s Tale. Yellowjackets is primed for, at worst, an acting nomination for Melanie Lynskey, but, overall, it could suffer from this season’s more mixed reception relative to Season One. Similarly, Handmaid’s muted response this season could hurt the show. Another returning Emmy nominee is The Boys. While its early release date can be tough to overcome, its rising popularity, increased acclaim, political relevance, and recent uptick in buzz due to some stellar campaigning could push the show to several nominations. New shows like The Old Man could receive some acting nods, but possibly come up short of an Outstanding Drama Series nod due to a tepid response to the show overall.
Lastly, you have House of the Dragon. Obviously, the Emmys have a soft spot for Game of Thrones, even awarding the show for its divisive final season, and Dragon was a mostly well-received and popular show. However, its performance at the guild awards makes me think the show’s hype has severely suffered since it has been off the air, and with HBO’s attention elsewhere, I have a feeling this spinoff might not impress the way one might think a Game of Thrones show would.
Outstanding Drama Series:
Succession
The Last of Us
The White Lotus
Better Call Saul
The Crown
Andor
Yellowjackets
The Boys
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series:
Kieran Culkin - Succession
Bob Odenkirk - Better Call Saul
Jeremy Strong - Succession
Pedro Pascal - The Last of Us
Diego Luna - Andor
Jeff Bridges - The Old Man
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series:
Sarah Snook - Succession
Melanie Lynskey - Yellowjackets
Bella Ramsey - The Last of Us
Imelda Staunton - The Crown
Emma D’Arcy - House of the Dragon
Elisabeth Moss - The Handmaid’s Tale
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series:
Matthew MacFadyen - Succession
F. Murray Abraham - The White Lotus
Alan Ruck - Succession
Alexander Skarsgård - Succession
Jonathan Pryce - The Crown
Jonathan Banks - Better Call Saul
Michael Imperioli - The White Lotus
John Lithgow - The Old Man
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series:
Jennifer Coolidge - The White Lotus
Rhea Seehorn - Better Call Saul
Aubrey Plaza - The White Lotus
Elizabeth Debicki - The Crown
Meghan Fahy - The White Lotus
Carol Burnett - Better Call Saul
J. Smith-Cameron - Succession
Sabrina Impacciatore - The White Lotus
Outstanding Direction for a Drama Series:
Mark Mylod - “Connor’s Wedding,” Succession
Peter Hoar - “Long, Long Time,” The Last Of Us
Mike White - “Arrividerci,” The White Lotus
Andrij Parekh - “America Decides,” Succession
Benjamin Caron - “Rix Road,” Andor
Anya Adams - “Burial,” Yellowjackets
Peter Gould - “Saul Gone,” Better Call Saul
Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series:
Jesse Armstrong - “Connor’s Wedding,” Succession
Mike White - “Arrividerci,” The White Lotus
Craig Mazin - “Long, Long Time,” The Last Of Us
Peter Gould - “Saul Gone,” Better Call Saul
Peter Morgan - “Gunpowder,” The Crown
Jessica Chou - “Herogasm,” The Boys
Tony Gilroy - “Rix Road,” Andor
COMEDY CATEGORIES
There’s certainly a mustachioed elephant in the room in the comedy categories. There’s no doubt in my mind that the reigning back-to-back champion, Ted Lasso, is going to return to receive a handful of nominations. However, the final season's mixed reception amongst critics and audiences alike makes me think it could miss some key nominations, especially since something has come along that could end its streak. I’m talking about Abbott Elementary. Even more critically acclaimed and beloved by audiences than the series’ award-winning first season, Abbott Elementary swept the winter awards (granted, Ted Lasso wasn’t in the running), and in my opinion, is bound to overperform on nomination morning. I expect more acting nominations than it received last year (four), and it could possibly take the top prize.
Returning Emmy favorites Barry and Only Murders in the Building are bound to hear their name called on July 12, although the latter’s early release date could result in missing out on some major nominations. A new show certain to receive attention is The Bear. With its second season airing recently to rave reviews, and Jeremy Allen White on a nice win streak for the role, I can’t imagine a world where The Bear doesn’t receive an Outstanding Comedy Series nomination.
For the remaining three slots in Outstanding Comedy Series, you have returning favorites The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel and What We Do in the Shadows. Both shows could suffer from the new voting system, especially a show like Shadows since it has spent its Emmy run on the bottom half of the lineup. As for Maisel, the show hit a rough patch in terms of its viewership, buzz is at an all-time low, and while its final season wasn’t bad per se, it certainly wasn’t what it once was. That said, it ended on such a high note that I suspect the three main players will once again get nominations, so it’s still very much in the hunt.
As for the new shows in contention, Poker Face is a big question mark. Rian Johnson’s mystery series has many possibilities above the line, and it’s positioned to be Peacock’s first foray into the Emmy race. Shrinking also has what it takes to get in, and it’s a shoo-in for, at worst, a Supporting Actor nomination and possible win for Harrison Ford. That said, the show’s slighter nature may not be every voter's cup of tea. And finally, you have Wednesday, which wasn’t exactly critically acclaimed, but its popularity and cultural impact could be enough to garner some votes, especially with Netflix’ recent awards push.
Outstanding Comedy Series:
Abbott Elementary
Ted Lasso
The Bear
Barry
Only Murders in the Building
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Shrinking
What We Do in the Shadows
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series:
Jeremy Allen White - The Bear
Jason Sudeikis - Ted Lasso
Bill Hader - Barry
Steve Martin - Only Murders in the Building
Jason Segel - Shrinking
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series:
Quinta Brunson - Abbott Elementary
Jenna Ortega - Wednesday
Rachel Brosnahan - The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Natasha Lyonne - Poker Face
Christina Applegate - Dead to Me
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series:
Harrison Ford - Shrinking
Brett Goldstein - Ted Lasso
Tyler James Williams - Abbott Elementary
Henry Winkler - Barry
Anthony Carrigan - Barry
Tony Shalhoub - The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Chris Perfetti - Abbott Elementary
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series:
Sheryl Lee Ralph - Abbott Elementary
Hannah Waddingham - Ted Lasso
Janelle James - Abbott Elementary
Ayo Edebiri - The Bear
Lisa Ann Walter - Abbott Elementary
Alex Borstein - The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Juno Temple - Ted Lasso
Outstanding Direction in a Comedy Series:
Bill Hader - “wow,” Barry
Christopher Storer - “Review,” The Bear
Declan Lowney - “So Long, Farewell,” Ted Lasso
Randall Einhorn - “Teacher’s Conference,” Abbott Elementary
Amy Sherman-Palladino - “Four Minutes,” The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Gail Mancuso - “That ‘90’s Pilot,” That ‘90s Show
Outstanding Writing in a Comedy Series:
Quinta Brunson - “Development Day,” Abbott Elementary
Brendan Hunt, Joe Kelly, and Jason Sudeikis - “So Long, Farewell,” Ted Lasso
Christopher Storer - “System,” The Bear
Bill Hader - “wow,” Barry
John Hoffman, Matteo Borghese, and Rob Turbovsky - “I Know Who Did It,” Only Murders In the Building
Bill Lawrence, Jason Segel, and Brett Goldstein - “Coin Flip,” Shrinking
Marika Sawyer - “Go Flip Yourself,” What We Do in the Shadows
LIMITED CATEGORIES
To be blunt, this collection of categories is rough. It’s just slim pickings, which is why if my predictions seem to resemble other predictions you’ve seen, it’s because there aren't a lot of realistic options to choose from. Nonetheless, there are three shows that I’m fairly confident will not only score a nomination for the top prize, but multiple acting, writing, and/or directing nods based on their performances at the winter awards and popularity: Beef, Black Bird, and Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story.
Beyond those three, Daisy Jones & The Six and Fleishman is in Trouble seem like pretty safe bets, although one of these missing wouldn’t fully surprise me. Daisy Jones is a reasonably popular show, and it’s a very easy show for the average voter to get on board with, which could very well lead to multiple acting nominations. However, the show’s generally middling reviews could hold it back. As for Fleishman is in Trouble, reviews are glowing, but it never really took off. Plus, other than Claire Danes, none of the actors are seriously poised for a nomination. Still though, like I said above, there aren’t a lot of options otherwise.
The most likely option aside from those mentioned thus far is George & Tammy. It was received well enough, and stars Jessica Chastain and (maybe) Michael Shannon will most certainly earn nods. The main hurdle this miniseries faces is that it came and went so quickly that I don’t know how many voters actually saw it or will go out of their way to vote for it. The only other options I’m really considering are The English, Love & Death, The Patient, and Welcome to Chippendales, and that is mostly because they might receive major acting nominations.
Outstanding Limited Series:
Black Bird
Beef
Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Fleishman is in Trouble
Daisy Jones & The Six
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Limited Series:
Ali Wong - Beef
Jessica Chastain - George & Tammy
Riley Keough - Daisy Jones & The Six
Lizzy Caplan - Fleishman is in Trouble
Elizabeth Olsen - Love & Death
Rachel Weisz - Dead Ringers
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited Series:
Evan Peters - Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Taron Egerton - Black Bird
Steven Yeun - Beef
Jesse Eisenberg - Fleishman is in Trouble
Michael Shannon - George & Tammy
Steve Carell - The Patient
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Limited Series:
Niecy Nash-Betts - Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Claire Danes - Fleishman is in Trouble
Camila Morrone - Daisy Jones & The Six
Maria Bello - Beef
Ashley Park - Beef
Michael Learnerd - Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Nabiyah Be - Daisy Jones & The Six
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited Series:
Paul Walter Hauser - Black Bird
Richard Jenkins - Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Ray Liotta - Black Bird
Young Mazino - Beef
Joseph Lee - Beef
Domhnall Gleeson - The Patient
Rodney Burford Jr. - Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Outstanding Directing for a Limited Series:
Michaël Roskam - “Pilot,” Black Bird
Lee Sung Jin - “Figures Of Light,” Beef
Paris Barclay - “Silenced,” Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Valerie Faris and Jonathan Dayton - “Me-Time,” Fleishman Is In Trouble
Jake Schreier - “The Great Fabricator,” Beef
Joe Chappelle - “The Place I Lie,” Black Bird
Outstanding Writing for a Limited Series:
Lee Sung Jin - “The Bird’s Don’t Sing, They Screech In Pain,” Beef
Dennis Lehane - “The Place I Lie,” Black Bird
Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan - “Bad Meat,” Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
David McMillan and Janet Mock - “Silenced,” Dahmer: Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
Taffy Brodesser-Akner - “Me-Time,” Fleishman Is In Trouble
Scott Neustadter - “Track 5: Fire,” Daisy Jones & The Six